How To Get Insurance After Nonrenewal

How To Get Insurance After Nonrenewal

Facing insurance coverage and policy cancellation can leave you uncertain about your protection options. There are several reasons for insurance nonrenewal, such as your claims history and your increased risk assessment profile. You must understand what to do if your insurance company drops you and how to get new coverage.

As home insurance experts, we can give you the resources and guidance you need to move forward. 

Understanding Nonrenewal

If your insurance company decides not to renew your policy, it could be due to changes in underwriting guidelines, increased risk factors or company’s business decisions. In such a situation, you should receive notice from your insurance provider well before the policy expiration date, typically informing you of the nonrenewal and explaining their decision. Your notice period may vary according to state, but in Missouri, you must receive 30 days’ written notice with valid justification. 

Your insurance provider may choose not to renew your policy for several reasons. 

  • Filing too often: You have filed too many claims, including ones that might seem false or fraudulent.
  • Coverage withdrawal: Your insurance provider has pulled out of your state or ended your line of coverage.
  • Late premium payments: Missing or paying your premiums late may result in nonrenewal. Contact your provider to lower your coverage limits or raise your deductible if you struggle to pay your insurance premiums. 
  • Credit score hit: Check your credit score — a sudden drop can signify a risk to insurance providers, leading to nonrenewal. 
  • High-risk items: Adding high-risk items like a pool or trampoline makes you more likely to file costly claims. Your insurance provider may decide to cancel your policy if you buy several of these things.
  • Natural disaster increase: If your area sees an increase in natural disasters, your insurance provider may withdraw coverage as your risk of claims grows.
Contact Us Today!

The Consequences Of Insurance Nonrenewal

Being proactive is a must when you have confirmation that your insurance coverage is ending. Acting quickly will bolster your case to get new coverage and indicate your commitment to responsibility. Consider taking the following steps to build a strong application.

  • Make improvements: Lower your risk profile by updating your home without potentially pushing up your premiums. These improvements can include enhancing safety measures and fixing things like faulty pipes or electrical concerns.
  • Get a copy of your claim history report: Request a copy of your claims history report to verify your claims information and dispute any inaccuracies with your current insurance provider.
  • See if they will reconsider: With your claims history report ready, call your broker or insurance company to ask them to reconsider withdrawing coverage.

Assessing Your Insurance Needs Post-Nonrenewal

When your insurer does not renew your policy, you must start looking for alternative options based on your updated circumstances. Request quotes from several different insurers to find the most suitable coverage at a competitive rate. Remember to act promptly to avoid any gaps in your protection.

Start by evaluating your requirements based on your potential risks, assets and liabilities. You should also assess your previous policy to determine opportunities for improvement. Consider the following options.

How To Get Insurance After Nonrenewal
  • Shared-market options: If you have a high-risk home, consider the Fair Access to Insurance Requirements plan available in your state. These plans come with higher premiums but may give you the exact coverage you need.
  • Explore surplus: Surplus lines depend on your location, as these providers offer highly specialized coverage.
  • Evaluate assets and liabilities: Take stock of your assets and consider your abilities, like financial obligations and outstanding debts. Use this information to calculate the level of coverage you need to protect your assets and mitigate potential risks.

Improving Your Risk Profile For Future Insurers

Nonrenewal adversely affects your insurance history, representing a risk factor to other insurers. You must find ways of appealing to new providers. Use positive factors to demonstrate your reliability and responsibility, like a stable employment history, participation in risk-reducing activities or homeownership. Here are some other crucial components of a successful insurance application after nonrenewal.

  • Provide accurate information: Report the correct information about yourself, your assets and liabilities, along with relevant insurance history.
  • Explanation of circumstances: Clarify your situation, including the steps you are taking to address any underlying issues.
  • Be transparent: Use your claims history report as supporting documentation.
  • Proof of risk mitigation: Offer proof of your efforts to improve your insurability. Include any safety measures you are implementing, how you are raising your credit score and addressing previous claims.
Get a Free Quote

Role Of Insurers And Insurance Agents

After nonrenewal, insurers will assess your risk factors to determine your coverage eligibility. Insurance agents or brokers act as intermediaries to guide you through the processes and advocate for you as they help you find suitable replacement coverage. Here’s how they can help you secure insurance after nonrenewal.

  • Access to several providers: As brokers work with multiple insurance companies and policies, they give you access to many coverage options for your needs. This benefit is valuable to high-risk customers.
  • Risk assessment: Brokers can assess your risk profile, helping you understand how nonrenewal impacts you. They use this information to help you understand home insurance for your profile and strengthen your application.
  • Negotiation: Brokers have the experience to negotiate with insurance companies on your behalf, leveraging their relationships with these companies to advocate for your interests.
  • Claims assistance: Help from brokers also includes post-insurance benefits. They can help you file claims, make policy changes and solve problems you encounter along the way.
How To Get Insurance After Nonrenewal

Find Affordable Coverage From David Pope Insurance Services, LLC

Insurance nonrenewal is a challenging circumstance. Still, when you take proactive steps like evaluating your homeowners insurance needs, addressing contributing factors and exploring your options, you will restore your peace of mind. Nonrenewal does not define your insurability — instead, it is an opportunity to reassess your needs. Start with insurance brokers for nonrenewal cases. 

With over 20 years of industry experience, the knowledgeable team at David Pope Insurance is ready to help you find your new provider. We shop around to get you the lowest rates and premiums. Contact us today for personalized solutions and to request your fast, free insurance quote.

icon-angle icon-bars icon-times